City of Alexandria

Public scrutiny of the youth sports industry has largely been distilled into one topic in recent months — stay-to-play.

The concept is easy to understand. Hotel booking is a universal experience, regardless of personal ties to youth sports. The practice has drawn lawmakers’ ire and spurred a pair of federal lawsuits. It became a “South Park” punchline this week. And, for the most part, it is presented as an example of private equity and other for-profit operators running amok at the expense of families— the literal focus of the proposed Let Kids Play Act.

But like with almost every other popular industry-related debate and narrative, stay-to-play is far more nuanced than typically presented.

Case in point: The recently-proposed $117M youth sports and entertainment complex in Alexandria, Virginia, which will be a public-private partnership between the city and ALX Sports, a new non-profit organization backed by the Alexandria Soccer Association.

Among the deal terms: City officials are mandating ALX Sports enforce stay-to-play policies for complex events to “ensure anticipated  visitor-driven fiscal benefits are realized.”

ALX Sports will be required to induce hotel stays and other local economic activity through contracts with the majority of tournament and event organizers. A penalty mechanism will be included in the future agreement requiring ALX Sports to pay the resulting revenue shortfall to the Public Entities if the policy is not applied or a pre-determined percentage of the fiscal impacts are not realized.

The city will also require ALX Sports to share naming rights revenues and hit quotas for the "number, type, and attendance of national, regional and local events.”

And if the numbers do not hit the targets? It’s on the non-profit to cover the difference.

Our Take: We have a city right down the road from Capitol Hill going on the record to co-sign many arguments and points that stay-to-play advocates make:

  • STP is a legitimate practice for an event-based industry

  • STP is a necessary tool for most projects’ viability

  • STP proves economic impact to cities and municipalities

  • STP subsidizes events and, if removed, costs would still exist or possibly increase

That last point is perhaps the most important one. The city has made it crystal clear that it will be made whole. And if stay-to-play does not get it across the financial finish line, then ALX Sports will.

Play that out: The non-profit would likely then need to increase rental fees. Or registration fees or admission and parking fees or the cost of hot dogs at the snack shack. However it shakes out, the burden would then almost assuredly get passed down to families. This is also why STP policies come with buyout fees — another popular bugaboo for detractors.

Put more bluntly: While there are rational arguments to be made on both sides about the volume of travel in youth sports, the reality is that stay-to-play economics subsidize the very existence of many facilities that provide much-needed local infrastructure outside of the large tournaments they host.

That said, good actors in the industry agree that stay-to-play practices must be transparent and need to deliver actual savings for families. But this situation in Alexandria is a reminder that reflexively ascribing the practice to deception and greed - or more specifically, private equity - as some have is often on off-base, or misses part of the story.

As for the project details: The proposed site is a regional park that currently hosts a seasonal water park and related attractions.

The city plans to issue $107M in bonds to fund the project with ALX Sports pledging to raise the other $10M. The non-profit will manage the complex under a 30-year lease with annual rent starting at $2.5M.

  • 210K-square-foot indoor facility

  • Mix of courts, turf fields

  • Spectator areas, locker rooms

  • Food and beverage offerings

  • 50K square feet of outdoor community, park elements

  • About 600 parking spots

  • Close to two Washington D.C. Metro stations

The city said it projects the complex will generate $160M in revenues for public services over the lifetime of the lease, including $20M toward affordable housing.

The complex would be within “a day’s drive” for about 50% of the U.S. population, according to the proposal, citing a 10-hour driving radius.

Stay tuned: City leaders held an initial public forum last night that reportedly was “heated” at times with “pointed questions” from residents. There will be several more public events leading up to a potential city council vote in mid-January.

🤳 Follow Buying Sandlot And Buying Media Group

Follow, connect, and partner with Buying Media Group — going deep on the business of sports.

Follow Buying Sandlot on social:

Connect with us on LinkedIn:

Sponsorship Inquiries: